Top artists in the collection:
| Tintoretto | Italian, 1518-1594 (Mannerism) | 10 artworks |
| Titian | Italian, 1485-1576 (High Renaissance) | 8 artworks |
| Winslow Homer | American, 1836-1910 | 7 artworks |
| Paul Gauguin | French, 1848-1903 (Post-Impressionist) | 6 artworks |
| John Singer Sargent | American, 1856-1925 | 6 artworks |
| Edvard Munch | Norwegian, 1863-1944 (Expressionist) | 6 artworks |
| Lyonel Feininger | American, 1871-1956 (Bauhaus) | 6 artworks |
| William Merritt Chase | American, 1849-1916 (Impressionist) | 5 artworks |
| Lucian Freud | German, 1922-2011 | 5 artworks |
| Alfred Sisley | French, 1839-1899 (Impressionist) | 5 artworks |
| Martin Johnson Heade | American, 1819-1904 | 5 artworks |
The Athenaeum has no exhibitions on record for this museum. Exhibition records can be added for this museum here.