Top artists in the collection:
| Charles Marion Russell | American, 1864-1926 | 13 artworks |
| Albert Bierstadt | American Hudson River School, 1830-1902 | 5 artworks |
| Frederic Remington | American, 1861-1909 | 5 artworks |
| Alfred Jacob Miller | American, 1810-1874 | 5 artworks |
| Thomas Worthington Whittredge | American, 1820-1910 | 1 artworks |
| William Jacob Hayes | American, 1830-1875 | 1 artworks |
| Henry F. Farny | American, 1847-1916 | 1 artworks |
| Thomas Mickell Burnham | American, 1818-1866 | 1 artworks |
| Karl Bodmer | Swiss, 1809-1893 | 1 artworks |
| William Henry David Koerner | American, 1878-1938 | 1 artworks |
| Newell Convers (N.C.) Wyeth | American, 1882-1945 | 1 artworks |
The Athenaeum has no exhibitions on record for this museum. Exhibition records can be added for this museum here.